CodeNewbie Community 🌱

Sharon428931
Sharon428931

Posted on

How SafeLine WAF Stacks Up Against Cloudflare and ModSecurity

Image description

In Part1,we covered how to deploy and configure SafeLine, a free and open source WAF built by Chaitin Tech.

Now it’s time to test it.


🔬 Smart Detection: Semantic Analysis Engine

SafeLine doesn’t rely on basic rule-matching. Its built-in semantic analysis engine deeply understands request intent, making it way more accurate against modern attacks.


🤖 Advanced Defense

  • Web attacks: SQLi, XSS, RCE, CRLF, XXE, SSRF, etc.
  • Bot Defense: CAPTCHA, rate limiting, anti-crawlers

Image description

  • HTTP Flood: Throttle IPs that exceed traffic thresholds

Image description

  • Authentication: Enforce login for sensitive endpoints

Image description

  • Threat Intelligence: Auto-block IPs from known bad actors

✅ Try Simulated Attacks

# SQL Injection
https://your-site.com/?id=1+and+1=2+union+select+1

# XSS
https://your-site.com/?id=<img+src=x+onerror=alert()>

# Path Traversal
https://your-site.com/?id=../../../../etc/passwd

# Code Injection
https://your-site.com/?id=phpinfo();system('id')

# XXE
https://your-site.com/?id=<?xml+version="1.0"?><!DOCTYPE+foo+SYSTEM+"">
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

Image description

Image description

🧪 Test with BlazeHTTP (WAF Benchmark Tool)

Run this Docker container to benchmark SafeLine’s protection:

docker run --rm --net=host chaitin/blazehttp:latest /app/blazehttp -t "http://127.0.0.1:8888"
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

📊 Real Test Results

WAF Accuracy Detection Miss Rate False Positives
SafeLine (Personal - Balanced) 99.45% 71.65% 28.35% 0.07%
SafeLine (Personal - Strict) 99.38% 76.17% 23.83% 0.22%
SafeLine (Pro - Strict) 99.66% 90.68% 9.32% 0.07%
CloudFlare 98.40% 10.70% 89.30% 0.07%
ModSecurity L1 82.39% 82.26% 17.74% 17.61%
ModSecurity L4 48.32% 96.77% 3.23% 52.49%

📌 Accuracy = (Correct Blocks + Correct Passes) / Total Samples

📌 Detection Rate = Correct Blocks / Attack Samples

📌 Miss Rate = Incorrect Passes / Attack Samples

📌 False Positive Rate = Incorrect Blocks / Normal Samples


⚙️ Performance Specs

  • Personal Edition: Lightweight, runs with just 1 CPU + 1GB RAM, handles ~800 QPS
  • Lite Edition: Efficient and low-resource friendly
  • Pro Edition: Full performance, maxes out server capacity

Minimum requirements:

  • CPU: 1 core
  • RAM: 2 GB
  • Disk: 60 GB, 2000 IOPS

Scale up: Add 1 core, 2 GB RAM, and 40 GB disk for every 1000 QPS.


🌍 Join the Community

➡️ Try SafeLine today — it's open source, battle-tested, and production-ready.

🏷️ Join the community, share feedback, and help us improve.

Top comments (1)

Collapse
 
orpha63 profile image
Duane Kshlerin

The side-by-side numbers with ModSecurity are eye-opening — SafeLine clearly outpaces in both accuracy and flexibility. Plus, it’s great to see a free, open-source tool standing strong against industry giants. Survival Race